Hire RulebookSubscribe

Countries / Japan / What Americans get wrong

What Americans get wrong in Japan

When a US team hires in Japan for the first time, the surprises are rarely the tax rates. They are the things that look familiar and then turn out to work differently: bonuses, dismissal, the commute, social insurance, and how notice actually runs. These notes are the ones we would walk through before the offer goes out.

1. Summer and winter bonuses are customary, not a legal extra

When we budget a Japan hire, it is easy to treat base salary as the whole story. Japanese companies typically pay monthly wages plus summer and winter bonuses, and those bonuses often make up a large share of yearly pay. The Labor Standards Act does not require a bonus unless you have promised one in the contract or the work rules. If you do pay bonuses, social insurance contributions apply to them as well as to monthly pay.

In my experience, candidates simply expect the bonus. It was never something we negotiated, and an offer that treated it as optional looked like a pay cut.

Source (custom, not statute): JETRO, 4.4 Wages

2. There is no at-will employment here

US managers sometimes assume they can end a hire with notice and a check. In Japan, a dismissal that lacks objectively reasonable grounds, and is not considered appropriate in general societal terms, is an abuse of rights and is invalid. On top of that, the Labor Standards Act generally requires at least 30 days' advance notice, or payment of average wages for that period, before a dismissal. Paying money to the employee does not, by itself, make a dismissal lawful.

I had to explain this to headquarters more times than I can count. You simply cannot fire someone in Japan. Period. Buyer's remorse does you no good. It takes one person to start a union. The practical answer we had was a negotiated payout, because if it goes to the labor authorities or the courts, you usually lose. We once had someone whose behavior toward colleagues was clearly unacceptable, and even then the realistic way out was paying him to leave. That's the hard truth.

Sources: Labor Contract Act, Article 16; Labor Standards Act, Article 20; JETRO, 4.8 Resignation and dismissal

3. A commuting allowance is expected, even though the statute does not require it

Monthly pay in Japan often includes allowances, and a transportation allowance is one of the usual ones. The law does not require a commuting allowance unless you put it in the contract or the work rules. Candidates will still ask what you pay for the commute, and a zero in that line can make an otherwise clean offer look incomplete. We do not invent a typical yen amount; set the policy in writing and apply it consistently.

Source (custom, not statute): JETRO, 4.4 Wages

4. Enroll in shakai hoken when you incorporate or hire, not once you "feel big enough"

A US company may wait for a headcount threshold it remembers from somewhere else. Official JETRO guidance is that a company must enter Japan's labor and social insurance systems when it first incorporates or hires staff, by filing the notifications with the relevant authorities. Coverage for part-time staff depends on their hours, so check the current official rules for the people you are actually hiring rather than assuming a short-hours role sits outside the system.

Source: JETRO, 4.9 Japan's social security system

5. At 10 employees you must file work rules

Once you continuously employ 10 or more workers, the Labor Standards Act requires you to prepare rules of employment and file them with the Labor Standards Inspection Office, and to file again if you change them. JETRO makes the same point and notes that smaller workplaces are encouraged to have rules anyway, because once the rules exist they can have the same force as a contract if their content is reasonable. Draft them carefully; they will govern hours, pay, leave and dismissal.

Source: Labor Standards Act, Article 89; JETRO, 4.6 Rules of Employment

6. You cannot lawfully require overtime without a 36 agreement

Statutory working hours are 40 hours a week and 8 hours a day, excluding breaks. To have people work beyond that, or on a statutory day off, you need a written labor-management agreement (the "36 agreement") and you must file it with the Labor Standards Inspection Office. Overtime and holiday work also attract premium pay: at least 25 percent in ordinary cases, and at least 50 percent once overtime in a month exceeds 60 hours.

US leaders are often surprised that the manager personally can face liability for overtime violations, not only the company. The Labor Standards Act makes hours and overtime-pay violations a criminal matter for the person who commits them. If a staff member commits the violation in connection with the business, the person in control of the business (and, if that is a corporation, its representative) can also be fined, unless they took the necessary measures to prevent it.

Sources: Labor Standards Act, Articles 32, 36 and 37 (hours, the 36 agreement, and premium pay); Articles 119 and 121 (penalties and liability of the person in control); JETRO, 4.5 Legislation on working hours, breaks and days off

7. Probation is not a free pass to dismiss

Japanese law does not set a standard probation length, so do not import a US 90-day at-will period and assume it will hold. The Labor Standards Act only carves out people still in a probationary period, and only for the first 14 days, from the usual 30-day dismissal-notice rule. A dismissal during probation is still judged under the Labor Contract Act: it needs objectively reasonable grounds and must be appropriate in general societal terms, or it is invalid.

Sources: Labor Standards Act, Article 21; Labor Contract Act, Article 16

8. An accepted offer is hard to take back

US teams sometimes treat an offer as something they can still pull if a problem turns up later. In Japan, if a preliminary offer of employment (naitei) is found to have formed a labor contract, cancelling it is treated as a dismissal. The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare says that, in those cases, a job offer cannot be withdrawn unless there is a justifiable reason based on generally accepted social standards.

We hired a manager without telling the team. They freaked, because he had a very bad reputation. We had not done the research. We made the offer, and the team threatened to quit. Then we looked into him, and the decision was to pull the offer. I had to explain that this could not happen. The company paid him to walk away. It was ugly. Do the reference checks, and tell the team, before the offer goes out.

Sources: MHLW, Understanding and Utilizing Labor Laws (preliminary offer of employment); Labor Contract Act, Article 16

9. Notice works differently on the way in and the way out

If we dismiss someone, we generally need 30 days' notice or pay in lieu, and the dismissal itself must still be valid under Article 16 of the Labor Contract Act. If an employee on an indefinite contract resigns, the Civil Code says employment ends two weeks after they ask to terminate. In practice, people often give longer notice than two weeks, and we should plan handovers on that basis without writing an unreasonably long resignation period into the rules.

Sources: Labor Standards Act, Article 20; Civil Code, Article 627; JETRO, 4.8 Resignation and dismissal

10. Decide external titles before you hire

US companies often treat job titles as internal status. In Japan, the title on a business card is how clients and counterparts decide whether you matter. This is custom, not a statute, but it is worth settling before the first offer goes out, including whether promotion letters can be written in Japanese.

Early in my Japan role, the Japanese team told me they were frustrated that their business cards had no proper titles. I wrote a proposal for Japanese external titles at department-head and division-head level. Headquarters pushed back on culture grounds. Legal found no risk, and it went through. That earned me real credibility, because for once, someone was representing them. I also got promotion documents allowed in Japanese. The promotion process should not be an English lesson.

Also worth knowing (custom, not statute)

Many Japanese employers review pay and move people in April, around the start of the government's fiscal year. That timing is custom, not a legal requirement. If you hire in the autumn, be ready to explain when the first review will be.

"Disagree and commit" does not really translate. People often will not push back on a boss in public, so honest feedback tends to come later and privately. If you only listen in the meeting, you can miss what people actually think.

Back to hiring in Japan