Countries / Germany / What Americans get wrong
What Americans get wrong in Germany
When a US team makes its first hires in Germany, the surprises are rarely the tax rate on the offer letter. They are the things that look familiar and then work differently: dismissal, notice, contracts, and the fact that a works council can appear once you have a handful of people, and then has a say in hiring tools and surveys. These notes are the ones we would walk through before the first German offer goes out.
1. Germany is not at-will, even with a small headcount
US managers sometimes assume that a shop of a few people is close enough to at-will. A dismissal or a termination agreement has to be in writing to be effective, and the electronic form is excluded. Once someone has been employed in the same establishment or company without a break for more than six months, a dismissal is invalid if it is socially unjustified, unless the establishment falls under the small-shop rule in the Dismissal Protection Act. For employees whose job started after 31 December 2003, those main protection rules do not apply in establishments that usually have ten or fewer employees, not counting people in vocational training. Part-time staff are counted as 0.5 if they regularly work no more than 20 hours a week, and as 0.75 if they work no more than 30. Even when that small-shop rule applies, the written-form requirement and the statutory notice periods still do. If the Dismissal Protection Act does apply, the employee generally has three weeks from receipt of the written dismissal to file a claim in the labor court.
Sources: Civil Code (BGB) section 623; Dismissal Protection Act (KSchG) section 1; KSchG section 23; KSchG section 4
2. Notice runs on a statutory clock, and probation is not automatic
The baseline notice period is four weeks, to the 15th or to the end of a calendar month. For a dismissal by the employer, the period then grows with length of service: one month to the end of the month after two years, two months after five years, and further steps up to seven months after 20 years. During an agreed probation period, and only for a maximum of six months, the employment can be ended with two weeks' notice. If you do not agree a probation period in the first place, you do not get that shorter clock. Probation is not a US-style at-will window, and a dismissal still has to be in writing.
Sources: BGB section 622; BGB section 623
3. A works council can be elected once you have five people, and it has a say in hiring tools
In an establishment that usually has at least five permanent employees who are entitled to vote, of whom three are eligible to be elected, a works council is elected. That is a right of the employees. It is not a body the employer has to set up in advance, and it is not something you can simply refuse. If a works council exists, it must be heard before every dismissal, and the employer has to give the reasons. A dismissal issued without that hearing is invalid. The works council also has co-determination rights that matter when you bring in a US hiring assessment or an HR tool. Personnel questionnaires need its consent, as do general assessment principles and guidelines on how people are selected for hiring. The same consent is needed before you introduce or use technical systems that are intended to monitor employees' behavior or performance. If the two sides cannot agree, a conciliation board can decide. The council gates a tool like that before launch, not after. Plan for written agreements, and for the time those discussions take, before you roll out a hiring assessment or an HR system.
I supported a rollout of a candidate cultural assessment in the hiring process. Working with the works councils was interesting, and it was also hard. They had a real say over things that affected employees, and if they simply did not like the assessment, it did not go forward, even if we thought it would help us hire better people. Headquarters wanted the applicant system and the pre-hire test to go live together. I split them. The system went first. The test went to the councils, and we turned it on only after they approved the final content. They also required us to switch it on one site at a time, so the global plan had to change. Local HR had to lead that work. Pushing from US headquarters was the wrong stance. There had to be assurances in writing, votes and discussions. It is a very different world over there.
Sources: Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) section 1; BetrVG section 102; BetrVG section 94; BetrVG section 95; BetrVG section 87
4. A hire can need a works council file, including CVs you did not keep
In companies that usually have more than 20 employees entitled to vote, the employer must inform the works council before every hire, lay the required application documents before it, give information about the people involved, and seek the works council's consent. The statute does not list every document by name. In my experience, that file included the CVs of the candidates we did not hire. We had a US form that did not collect those CVs, and we had to scramble. If you are hiring into a German operation that already has a works council and is over that headcount, build the file before the offer goes out.
Sources: BetrVG section 99
5. Assessment scores and field names can be a works council issue too
The works council's say does not stop at whether a hiring tool may be used. It can also affect what data you are allowed to keep. In my experience, the councils would not allow us to retain assessment scores, which blocked later checks on whether the assessment had been useful. Even a field labeled "Performance Data" raised concerns and had to be renamed or hidden. Agree the fields and the retention rules with the council before you launch, not after the first reports go out.
verify there is no single statute that says assessment scores may never be retained. This is what happened in Michael's case, under the co-determination rules already cited, and it may differ by site and by what the tool collects.
Sources: BetrVG section 87; BetrVG section 94
6. You have to hand over the essential terms on a statutory timetable
A handshake or a short email offer is not enough. The employer must set down the essential terms of the employment (including the parties, pay, hours, place of work, leave, notice and the other items listed in the statute) and give them to the employee. The names of the parties, the pay, and the hours are due by the first day of work. Several other items, including the start date and any agreed probation, are due by the seventh calendar day after the agreed start. The remaining items are due within a month of the agreed start. In many cases the terms may be sent in text form that the employee can save and print, and the employer must ask for an acknowledgement of receipt. That looser form is not available in certain sectors listed in the law on undeclared work. A later dismissal still has to be in writing under the Civil Code; that rule is separate.
Source: Act on proof of essential employment conditions (Nachweisgesetz) section 2
7. Vacation and sick pay are larger statutory items than many US teams budget
The Federal Vacation Act sets a minimum of 24 Werktage of leave a year. Werktage are all calendar days except Sundays and public holidays, so Saturday counts as a Werktag. The full entitlement is first acquired after six months of employment. Many employers grant more than the statutory minimum; that extra amount is a matter of contract or custom, not a figure we invent here.
If an employee cannot work because of illness, and it is not their fault, the employer must continue the regular pay for the period of incapacity, up to six weeks. The claim arises after the employment has lasted four weeks without a break. After those six weeks, statutory health insurance sick pay is a different regime, and we do not put a figure on it here.
Sources: Federal Vacation Act (BUrlG) section 3; BUrlG section 4; Continuation of Pay Act (Entgeltfortzahlungsgesetz) section 3; Entgeltfortzahlungsgesetz section 4
8. Watch the minimum wage, the hours cap, and the duty to record time
From 1 January 2026 the statutory minimum wage is 13.90 euros gross per hour. From 1 January 2027 it rises to 14.60 euros. The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs states that it applies to employees working in Germany, including people in minijobs and people employed by a foreign employer. There are limited statutory exceptions, including people under 18 without a completed vocational qualification, and a six-month exception for people who were long-term unemployed immediately before the job. Professional salaries are usually well above this floor, but the floor still has to be watched for interns, student hires and any hourly work.
Working time must not exceed eight hours on a working day. It may go up to ten hours only if the average over six calendar months or 24 weeks stays at eight hours a working day. The Working Time Act also requires the employer to record time that goes beyond those eight hours. Separately, the Federal Labor Court has held, and BMAS explains, that under the Occupational Health and Safety Act the employer must have a system that records the working time employees actually perform, including the start, end and duration of each day. BMAS says there is currently no required format; a handwritten record can suffice. A habit of trusting people to get the work done without a record does not remove that duty.
Sources: Fifth Minimum Wage Adjustment Ordinance (MiLoV5) section 1; BMAS, statutory minimum wage overview; Working Time Act (ArbZG) section 3; ArbZG section 16; BMAS, questions and answers on working-time recording
9. Register for social insurance when you hire
When you take someone on, you must register that person for social insurance. The official federal portal, published by the Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs, is clear: the duty covers all employees, including people in minijobs, trainees, interns and student workers, and the filings have to be made electronically. The employer is the one who has to pay the overall social insurance contribution; the employee's share is part of that payment. An employer of record in Germany can be the formal local employer, but that is a structuring choice, not a way to step around German labor law for the person doing the work. Whether a hire also creates a German taxable permanent establishment is a separate tax question that depends on the facts. We do not state a single PE rule here.
verify how a US company with only people working remotely in Germany is treated for permanent establishment. Official finance ministry guidance dated 18 June 2026 exists, but the ministry pages did not load reliably when this draft was written, so we have not relied on them.
Sources: Social Code Book IV (SGB IV) section 28a; SGB IV section 28e; Federal portal: register employees for social insurance
10. Get the contract type and the end date right
A fixed-term contract is one whose duration is set by a calendar date, or by a defined purpose. For the fixed term to be effective, it has to be in writing. A calendar-fixed contract ends when the agreed time runs out. An indefinite contract does not have an end date. If the fixed term is invalid, the law treats the contract as indefinite, and the employer generally cannot give ordinary notice before the date that had been agreed. A wrong end date, or the wrong contract type, is both a legal and a financial risk.
In my experience, a wrong end date or the wrong contract type was a real risk, and it was a blocker. Get the type and the date right before the person starts.
Sources: Part-Time and Fixed-Term Employment Act (TzBfG) section 3; TzBfG section 14; TzBfG section 15; TzBfG section 16
11. An employee survey is not exempt because it feels soft
If a works council exists, do not assume a staff survey can run without approval just because it feels informal. Sections 87 and 94 give the works council co-determination over certain questionnaires and over technical systems that can monitor employees. Whether a particular survey falls under those rules depends on what you ask and how you use the answers.
In my experience, the German sites had to wait for approval while the survey ran elsewhere. We held back the sharing of manager reports. Any new feature, or any later reuse of the answers, had to go back to the council. Get the approval before you launch, and go back if you change how the answers are used.
verify not every staff survey automatically falls under sections 87 or 94. The legal fit depends on the questions, the tool, and the use of the answers. Have German counsel look at the actual survey.
Sources: BetrVG section 87; BetrVG section 94
12. A post-contract non-compete is not binding unless you pay for it
A clause that restricts someone's work after they leave is binding only if it is in writing, a signed document is handed to the person, and the employer undertakes to pay compensation for the duration of the restraint of at least half of the most recent contractual benefits, for each year of the restraint. The restraint cannot be extended for more than two years after the employment ends. It is also not binding if it does not protect a legitimate business interest, or if, taking the compensation into account, it unreasonably hinders the person's professional progress. The Commercial Code text is written for commercial employees (Handlungsgehilfen).
verify German courts apply these same Commercial Code rules to employees who are not commercial clerks. Have German counsel confirm this for the role you are hiring.